Follow Us On
Stretching Out
Stretching Out

Written by Dwight Normile    Thursday, 19 August 2010 11:43    PDF Print
Stretching Out: Stoica, Singapore & the IG Tour
(6 votes, average 3.33 out of 5)

The September IG is coming out soon, and it includes an interview with FIG Men's Technical Committee President Adrian Stoica. I asked him several questions about the Code of Points, such as whether the MTC considered lowering the counting skills from 10 to eight ("no"); does he think the men's routines are too long and should have a skill limit ("it is not necessary"); and how could Kohei Uchimura score an 8.775 (execution) on high bar at the 2009 worlds for one of the most beautiful routines in gymnastics history (he agreed, somewhat)?

There is a lot more to the interview, and Stoica was diplomatic, of course. But I also appreciated his candor. After all, he's got a tough job.

Men's Vault Proposal

Speaking of Stoica, I read with interest his proposal for men's vault in the July FIG Bulletin. Stoica is suggesting that men do two vaults in all phases of competition, and their final score will be (DVt1 + DVt2)/2 + [10-(Sum of average deductions for Vt1 and Vt2)].

It's not as confusing as it sounds. Here is a practical application: Gymnast does a 7.0 first vault and a 6.6 second vault. His final D-score is the average: 6.8. His execution scores for the two vaults are 9.6 and 9.4, so his final execution score is 9.0 (add the deductions from both vaults and subtract from 10). Final score: 15.80.

The gymnast can do the same vault twice without penalty, but he must do two different vaults to qualify for apparatus finals.

Stoica is soliciting feedback from "specialists around the world," so here goes. If the goal is to bring the average vault score down, and in line with the other five apparatus, then I believe a simpler solution would be to lower all of the vault values. Doubling the execution deductions from a single vault would also accomplish the goal. But I am fundamentally against any proposal that adds to the already taxing physical requirements of the male gymnast under this Code. If the MTC eventually decides to shorten men's routines across the board, then I'd consider the two-vault rule.

Youth Olympics: Kamoto and Komova

Yuya Kamoto and Viktoria Komova have been the gymnastics stars of the inaugural Olympics in Singapore so far, and I can't help but think the U.S. made a big mistake in not sending one of its top junior women, such as the extremely talented Jordyn Wieber. At the Visa Championships in Hartford last week, I asked U.S. national team coordinator Marta Karolyi if she regretted not sending a gymnast to Singapore. She said "yes and no," and then gave various reasons why they chose not to send someone. "Maybe we would have decided differently if we knew the personal coach could go," she said." Eventually, the IOC permitted the extra coach, but the U.S. had already turned down its women's spot. But I'm left to wonder how every other major gymnastics nation found a way to participate. Any time you can compete in—or even win—a meet that has the word Olympics in it, you should go for it.

IG Tour to Rotterdam

There is still time to sign up for the IG Tour to the 2010 World Championships in Rotterdam, site of the first IG Tour in 1987. Kermit and Jean Davis organized that inaugural tour, and they are still running the show today. The tour dates are Oct. 14-25 and includes airfare, hotel and tickets to all gymnastics sessions. Email International Sports Exchange for information: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

National Gymnastics Day — September 18, 2010

Click here to find out how your gym club can participate and help support the Children's Miracle Network. National Gymnastics Day was established in 1999, and more than $1 million has been raised.

My Story

After printing "My First Front Flip(s)" in July on the IG website, I asked readers to send in their own personal stories about their experiences in gymnastics. Funny, sad, inspirational, whatever. We received some great ones, and they will appear in future issues of IG. The first will be published in the October issue, and it was written by a woman whose love for the sport inspired her to launch her own gymnastics magazine. (I won't say who she is.) Everyone has a story, so please tell us yours.

"My Story" Submission Guidelines: Email text (750-1,500 words) to This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it . Subject Line: "My Story." Attach JPEG head shot and/or other photos relevant to your story. Images should be at least 300K.

Written by Dwight Normile    Tuesday, 20 July 2010 15:33    PDF Print
Stretching Out: Welcome back, Paul Hamm
(19 votes, average 3.95 out of 5)

When Paul Hamm opted for retirement after winning the 2004 Olympic all-around gold, I was against it. Not that it was up to me, or anything. But I wanted to see what kind of winning streak he could put together, since he had won the 2003 worlds in Anaheim, too. The U.S. had waited a long time for an all-arounder of Hamm's caliber, and then circumstances drained his motivation right at his peak.

Through no fault of his own — but rather to a judging error — Hamm ended up in a very public debate regarding the legitimacy of his Olympic title. He was forced to defend his gold medal immediately after it was placed around his neck. So it was understandable that he might want to take a break.

I was pleased when he and his twin, Morgan, decided to come back for a run at 2008, even if Paul's chance at dominating the quadrennium in the all-around had already passed.

Then, after he worked himself back into national-title form by the spring of 2008, Hamm sustained a hand injury on parallel bars at the U.S. championships in Houston. A fractured fourth metacarpal ultimately aborted his return to the Olympics. And even counting his ill-fated fall from p-bars at those nationals, Hamm still logged a 93.450, 3.70 clear of second place.

China's Yang Wei won the 2008 Olympic gold with room to spare, scoring 94.575. Current world champion Kohei Uchimura, who fell twice from pommel horse, was next with 91.975. Hamm would have made it much more interesting in Beijing.

I've often said that comebacks never surprise me, but Hamm's does. And it's one that I welcome. He'll be close to 30 by the summer of 2012, but perhaps a few years younger, physically. He hasn't trained non-stop since 2004 like many of his contemporaries. And even though only five gymnasts will make the 2012 Olympic team, Hamm's all-around ability should make him a lock.

Hamm recently quit his job at Breakwater Trading in Chicago and has been training a bit at his old gym, Swiss Turners, in West Allis, Wis., where coach Andrei Kan has been "just kind of busting my butt [laughs]." He's also reconciled with his old coach, Stacy Maloney, whom he left after the 2003 worlds. Hamm says he will train full-time at either Swiss Turners or the USOTC in Colorado Springs.

Hamm told me his goals for 2012 are to help the team and to contend in the all-around and on high bar. He's also aware of Uchimura's current dominance.

"He's one of the people that is motivating me right now, because I see him and I realize how darn good he is," Hamm told IG. "And it makes me want to beat him, because of what an accomplishment that truly would be. But he is very good. He's an awesome gymnast."

After 2012, Hamm says he can always go back to his job in Chicago. But for now, he's putting his gymnastics career first.

"That (job) will be there for me later on, and I don't know how much longer my body will last," said Hamm, adding that he'd like to return to competition at the 2011 Winter Cup. "So I'm not going to let this opportunity pass me by."

When I spoke with Paul at length about his comeback, his voice revealed an enthusiasm that was missing after 2004. Time seems to have healed a few wounds.

Welcome back, Paul. Give it your best shot.

Read the complete interview with Paul Hamm in the next issue of IG.

Written by Dwight Normile    Tuesday, 13 July 2010 09:28    PDF Print
Stretching Out: Here's My Story; What's Yours?
(15 votes, average 4.40 out of 5)

IG has received some wonderful personal stories through the years. An upcoming issue, for example, will include "A Girl and Her Knee: One gymnast's candid account of what really happens after you tear an ACL" by Diana Gallagher. Two summers ago, Kathy Nimmer submitted "What Matters Most," her inspiring account of learning gymnastics while losing her eyesight. Betsy Cooper wrote "Gymnastics from the Other Side: How television and the Internet have changed the fan experience."

Everyone has a personal story, whether it's funny, sad, embarrassing or inspiring. And IG would like to share your stories with its readers. So if you are a gymnast, coach, judge, parent or diehard fan, send us your story. (See below on how to submit your story.)

As an example, following is an edited version of a story that first appeared in the May 1993 IG.

My First Front Flip(s)

By Dwight Normile

My name is Dwight, and I'm a gymnasticaholic. I'm addicted to gymnastics and have been for a long time. I think there are a lot of us out there, some more seriously affected than others.

It all began in elementary school. My older sister was on the high school gymnastics team, and I got dragged to her meets. At first, I was one bored fourth-grader, but I soon fell under gymnastics' magic spell. I was amazed that these seemingly normal high school students could perform complete flips — on a basketball floor! — under their own power. It just didn't seem natural, or possible. Hence, the lure of the sport for me. I wanted to learn how to flip, and the sooner the better.

Unfortunately, I had nowhere to practice, no one to teach me. At age 10 I wanted to do gymnastics, but it was frustrating to know I had to wait until high school to join the team. You can only do so much off the diving board in summer, or at home. I managed a back flip to my knees on my bed once, cautiously aware of an eight-foot ceiling. But when I tried to show a friend my new skill, I leaned back too far on the takeoff, landed off the bed, and crashed my neck hard against the wall. I quickly learned how humbling and humiliating gymnastics could be. Not to mention painful.

Not satisfied with flips aided by diving boards or bedsprings, I devised a plan to execute one on my own. My first solo front flip took place in the fall of 1966. I was 11.

After raking leaves in the back yard one day, I was struck with a brilliant idea. If I piled the leaves at the base of our hill, I could create an above-ground pit. The angle of the slope was just enough to help me complete a flip. It was perfect.

Realizing my attempts might be limited, I summoned my sister to record the historic moment. "Bring your Polaroid Swinger," I ordered.

I wanted my sister to snap a picture precisely when I was upside-down, so my friends would believe in awe that I had actually done a flip. She agreed to try. I paced off my approach at the top of the hill, knowing how crucial the takeoff point would be. I was ready. My Jack Purcells felt light and springy, my V-neck sweater loose yet soft to help absorb a rough landing.

My plan was to jump off the top of the bank, flip hard, land on my feet and plow into the leaves with a shoulder roll. After all, I would be landing halfway down a hill. If I didn't roll, my momentum would surely slam me into the side of the house.

Like all gymnasts, I faced the moment of truth as I contemplated the next few seconds. No backing out now; the camera crew was poised and ready. My biggest fear was landing on my butt, which would mean a painful defeat, physically and psychologically.

I had done front flips on trampolines and off diving boards, but now I would try one without the aid of springs—or mats. To me, this was what gymnastics was all about. A success here would elevate my status among peers. "He can do a flip," they would say.

OK, no more stalling. "Ready?" I asked my sister. She nodded. Feeling a bit like Evel Knievel, I ran, jumped, tucked and experienced my self-created thrill to its fullest. Everything went to plan. It was all so easy.

"Did you get it?" I asked, brushing leafy debris off my sweater. We waited for the instant photo to develop before our eyes. In fear of missing the shot, my sister had snapped the shutter immediately after takeoff. (A Polaroid Swinger is slightly slower than a Nikon D3.) I was still upright, barely off the ground. I had no proof. Better try again.

My second attempt was also a success, the photo perfect this time. I now had visual evidence that, at age 11, I was a little nuts. And for that I blame gymnastics.

How to Submit Your Story

Email story to: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Subject Line: My Story

Copy and paste the text of your story (between 750-1,500 words) into the body of your email.

Attach JPEG head shot and other photo(s) relevant to your story. Images should be at least 300 K in size (or straight from your digital camera).

Written by Dwight Normile    Friday, 18 June 2010 12:30    PDF Print
Stretching Out: Cal's Precarious Future & an Update From Romania
(5 votes, average 5.00 out of 5)

2012 would be the 100th anniversary of Cal men's gymnastics, and I'm sure I'm not alone in hoping it reaches that milestone. But the winds of economic gloom, particularly in the great state of California, have caused considerable concern among the Cal gymnastics faithful.

"No announcement has been made about program cuts here at Cal," said head coach Barry Weiner (shown here), who just completed his 19th season with the Golden Bears. "However, with the poor economic climate in the state of California, our athletic director, Sandy Barbour, has clearly stated nothing is off the table, including program cuts. Therefore, the Cal men's gymnastics family is asking for letters of support."

Weiner, an ardent student of the sport, led Cal to back-to-back NCAA titles in 1997 and 1998, and his gymnasts claimed three of the top six ranks at the 2009 U.S. championships.

The cuts are slated for late July or early August. If you are a supporter of Cal gymnastics—or simply a supporter of gymnastics—log on to to see how you can help. It would be a shame to lose a program that enhances both the NCAA and USA Gymnastics.

Bellu, Bitang back in the gym

IG reported earlier that Romanian women's national coach Nicolae Forminte resigned in a huff after learning that the expertise of his predecessors, Octavian Bellu and Mariana Bitang, had been solicited by the Romanian federation. Forminte later came to his senses and said he would reconsider his rash decision to quit.

Forminte's sudden resignation certainly took federation officials by surprise, but now, a few weeks later, his return apparently is no longer needed. With the national team on vacation from school right now, they have been training in Izvorani. Bellu and Bitang have been in the gym daily and running the workouts, along with other national team coaches.

Word out of Romania is that the atmosphere in the gym is very positive, so don't expect Forminte to be welcomed back. And while nothing is set in stone yet for the Rotterdam worlds in terms on who will coach the team, it wouldn't surprise me to see Bellu and Bitang return to their former head coaching roles at some point before 2011.

Written by Dwight Normile    Tuesday, 01 June 2010 11:58    PDF Print
Stretching Out: Olympic Qualification & Guess Who's Back? (updated)
(11 votes, average 3.18 out of 5)

The FIG announced the qualification process for the 2012 London Olympics, which will feature five-member teams for the first time. The 2010 Rotterdam World Championships in October will reportedly be the largest ever in terms of number of participants, but only the top 24 men's and women's teams will advance to the 2011 Tokyo World Championships.

2012 Olympic qualification

The format for Tokyo will differ from past Olympic qualifiers. Instead of the top 12 teams advancing to the Olympics, only the top eight teams, plus individual apparatus medalists, will earn Olympic berths.

In January 2012, the teams that placed ninth through 16th in Tokyo will battle for the last four team berths to London. This final qualification meet will be held at London's O2 Arena, the venue of the 2009 worlds and 2012 Olympics.

Having the final qualifier at home could help Great Britain secure berths for both its men's and women's teams. Its men's team did not qualify for the 2008 Beijing Olympics (it placed 15th at the 2007 Stuttgart worlds), and its women's team placed ninth in Beijing.

Give these guys a break

The Rotterdam worlds, which expanded its competition schedule from seven to nine days, also seems to have altered the usual meet format. For years, the men's qualification rounds preceded the women's, but the schedule printed on the official Rotterdam worlds website has the women's prelims on Oct. 16 and 17, followed by the men's prelims on Oct. 18 and 19.

The women's team final is slated for Oct. 20, the men's on Oct. 21. Then it gets weird.

Both the men's and women's all-around finals are scheduled for the same day, Oct. 22, with the men's at 4 p.m. and the women's at 7:30 p.m. So much for celebrating your team victory the night before if you are an all-arounder.

I feel for any all-arounder from a top-eight team, such as Japan's Kohei Uchimura or Germany's Fabian Hambüchen. These guys will have to gear up for the all-around final less than 24 hours after competing in the emotionally draining team final, where they might have performed on all six events. It will be completely understandable if any of these guys fails to reach his potential in the apparatus finals the following two days.

Why schedule the men after the women for the prelims and team finals, only to reverse them for the all-around finals? With only four events (and eight skills counting) compared with six (10 skills) for men, it is far easier for female gymnasts to compete back-to-back all-around competitions than it is for men.

If the FIG insists on holding a world championships in every non-Olympic year, perhaps it would be wise to follow the "individual" worlds (London 2009) with a shorter, team-only format the following year. No need to decide individual world champions again. Remember, years ago the worlds were held only every four years, between the Olympics. They were a really big deal, but not so much anymore. This year the Commonwealth Games will be held in New Delhi, India, from Oct. 3-14. The gymnastics competition runs from Oct. 4-8, and podium training for the Rotterdam worlds begins Oct. 12. That's a lot to ask of the Commonwealth teams that also need to be peaking in Rotterdam.

Keatings the latest casualty

I was saddened to hear about the ACL injury to Great Britain's Daniel Keatings. Saddened both for him and for what the sport will be missing in the short term. He sustained the injury shortly after the recent Birmingham Europeans. Again, the Europeans used to be a rarely contested event, but the European Gymnastics Union now holds them annually.

The open-ended Code has been in effect since 2006, and I have to believe that the longer routines for men combined with the growing frequency of competition is going to take a toll beyond our wildest nightmares.

Shawn Johnson also tore an ACL this year, but on the ski slopes. So just when you thought her gymnastics retirement had been confirmed by an injury, the opposite occurred. Apparently the setback spurred a comeback, which she announced recently. My guess is she won't be the only one. London 2012 will be here before you know it.

Bellu's back (updated)

When former Romanian head coach Octavian Bellu and his former assistant Mariana Bitang were recently asked by the Romanian Federation to help prepare the 2012 Olympic team, the sudden resignation of head coach Nicolae Forminte came as a surprise. The plan was not to have Bellu and Bitang move to Deva to take over, but to periodically work with Forminte to help the team. Now reports out of Romania say that Forminte might reconsider his decision to quit.


Page 8 of 18